Okay, I don't know why, but I did go ahead and got a year of the Online Expansion. It was a stupid impulse move that I knew I was going to regret. But I did get it. Soooo, here's a few positives, a few negatives. Let me just go app by app though.
Animal Crossing DLC
I don't play Animal Crossing. This is useless to me. I hope that maybe each month they have a different DLC pop up like how Sony introduces new games to their plus service each month. But that's just a hope. I don't know what Nintendo plans and as of right now, this is useless to me. What would have been better is if they'd put a bunch of different DLC options up and allowed you to choose one per month. But whatever. No positive here unless you actually own Animal Crossing.
_____
GAME SELECTION
Genesis App
I double checked. The only game on here that is not already on the Genesis Mini and/or the already existing Genesis collection is Musha. A decent shmup, but still, if you're going to be charging premium prices for this expansion, it would be nice to have more than one game that's not already widely available on other collections. But we already knew this, so let's get into the real meat and potatoes.
Nintendo 64 App
Okay, let's just go through this. I already have Ocarina of Time, Starfox 64 and Mario 64 in several different ways. I would imagine most people do. Between 3DS Remasters for Zelda and Star Fox, Switch Remaster for Mario and Virtual Console releases for all 3; these are the most recently widely available games from the N64 era. But of course they were going to put these on there. In fact, they were right to put them on there. Those are core games that absolutely belong. So enough about them.
Doctor Mario seems like how they put up Super Mario Allstars up on their SNES App when they already had all three Mario games on the NES App. Is it a better version? Sure! But it still feels like a game that could have waited a bit and given the slot to a more deserving game.
I will say I don't have, and like the inclusion of: Mario Kart, Mario Tennis, Win Back and Sin and Punishment. To be honest, it was probably Sin and Punishment that tipped me over into subscribing. It's one of those games I've never played but heard a lot about.
Over All
Game selection really just isn't that great. There's a few on the N64 that I'm glad are there. Now I know that more games are going to be added. But there's a question of what and when. We know some of the upcoming games. But if the recent months of releases on the NES and SNES apps are anything to go by, Nintendo has not had a great track record. We'll release new games whenever the hell we feel like it and who knows, one of them might actually be somewhat decent!
D+ There are some games I like. And this can be revisited once more games have come out. But for the money I just put into it, they're going to need to really make this library a priority if I'm going to renew next year.
_____
GRAPHICS
Now I know, these are several generation old games. What could I possibly be expecting. Well, I wasn't expecting much, which is why I was honestly pleasantly surprised.
If anyone's seen my ranking on Zelda, you know that I absolutely love Ocarina of Time. But one thing about it is that the graphics just have not aged well. Before the boards were destroyed, I even made a list of all the N64 games I owned and how they held up. One of my common complaints among the games were that the graphics just didn't hold up and some of them were even headache inducing. Ocarina of Time was one of the ones I claimed as headache inducing.
So I was surprised when I started playing Ocarina of time and...it actually looked pretty good. I mean, they didn't do any updating of the graphics or anything like that. It's still the same blocky early polygon graphics it's always been. But if only by uprezing it from CRT to HD, It honestly made it much easier to look at. I've been playing it for a bit and it hasn't even started to give me any of those headaches.
So for that alone, I have to give this some credit. It actually looks pretty good.
B+ It's still very much N64 graphics, but if only for a decent uprez from CRT to HD screens, my eyes are so grateful.
_____
CONTROLS
This is honestly actually where things get kinda bad. I mean, look, I know these games were made for the N64 controller and that it is probably the most...unique...controller ever made. But that didn't stop getting some damn good ports to the 3DS...and its controller is much more limited than the pro-controller or even the joy-cons. So I don't know. I mean, I'm getting used to it. But the darn right stick keeps getting in the way and I keep using items I don't mean to use...which can be troublesome not only in keeping items stocked, but getting yourself in trouble in the heat of battle. And I don't see any way of remapping either.
Sure there's a 64 controller specially made for these that you can buy. But for one thing, I'm not sure what the price tag is, but wasn't it in the neighborhood of $50? That's if you can find one. Scalpers are already having a field day with these.
Now, yes, I am getting used to it, kinda. The right stick still isn't great for c-buttons. But I guess looking at the controller, what else could they do. But "what else could they do" still leaves me with some non-intuitive controls.
C+ There's not much else they could do and I am getting used to it. But it's not nearly as comfortable as playing games on the other apps.
____
Over all.
This isn't even the first month. There is a lot of room for improvement. If they're smart (big if, but hear me out), Nintendo will hopefully make the available DLC more appealing to more people than just those playing Animal Crossing. They also need to vastly improve the game libraries.
Is it worth it?
Eh! Game selection is slightly better on the N64 app than Genesis. You'll notice I didn't even bother talking about Genesis for most of it. I'm also happy that the uprez from CRT to HD makes these games much easier on the eyes. But for $30 more than the base price for the normal Nintendo Online service.....?
Just wait. Honestly just wait. It's possible that as they add games and make different DLC's available...maybe it'll be worth the extra cost. But as it is right now, don't do what I did. It just isn't worth it. And if things don't improve drastically by the time my renew date is here, I'll most likely go back to basic.