honestly i don't know if i'd say magmatron dethrones armada optimus (the only other commander i have...if you don't count the ss86 optimus that is in the house but that's my christmas present so it's literally wrapped up and with the other presents right now) because like...my childhood attachment to armada prime does play a major factor in how much i like the figure vs 'character from a series i still haven't actually watched') but like...he sure is goddamn fun regardless.
now i wait for my fuckin stuff from my home in florida to fuckin arrive finally it's been so long because he can have ONE destron underling, as a treat (aka - i have a BWN guiledart)
I technically own them all but Motormaster, but have played with my friends and I'll likely get one once the G2 version is released, and SS86 Optimus who is also my christmas gift. I won't deny that personal feelings can play a big part in how someone ranks these guys. Armada wasn't my childhood, but I still have very strong fondness for the entire UT line. They hit at the right time in my life that I have almost the same fondness for them as I do G1, so Armada Prime was someone I jumped at when I was able to afford him. Got him and Magmatron within weeks of each other due to my birthday last month. So its not like Magmatron is just the "new hotness" to me.
Armada Prime is very good, but he's kinda like Jetfire to me. In that he feels very... standard at this price point. He's exactly as good as I expected him to be. Which honestly isn't a bad thing, because so far Commander Class' standard is still a very high bar. But Armada Prime is just
G1 Armada with knees, which
is what I want from a redo of him; but for me who's handled all commander Class toys he's still a truck and trailer and that's most the line. When you have guys like Ultra Magnus and Motormaster, he doesn't stand out as much. Again, this isn't really a knock against him, but is part of why Magmatron is just a bit higher for me. He's the first Beast Era guy, a guy with an already decent/cool toy if you have it. While the original Armada Prime is an extremely flawed toy no matter how much one might like it. That makes him more unique then the others, becuase the original toy is still again quite good for the era it means the improvements to him standout more because they're less obvious then Armada Prime's, which for me is slightly more impressive.